Frankie and the Witch Fingers are a high-voltage garage‑psych rock band
originally formed in Bloomington, Indiana, in 2013, now based in Los Angeles.
Anchored by co-founders Dylan Sizemore (vocals, rhythm guitar) and Josh Menashe
(lead guitar, synth), the lineup solidified with Nicole “Nikki Pickle” Smith
(bass) joining in 2019, Nick Aguilar (drums) in 2022, and Jon Modaff (synths) in
2025. Starting as a basement solo project by Dylan Sizemore, the band quickly
expanded into a full garage-rock outfit. Their early sound—surf‑tinged, lo‑fi
psych rock—morphed through successive albu...